Tested And Approved: The Euro Cuisine YM80 is the best yogurt maker as it offers all the features to let you control the final product. While making different Greek yogurt recipes, we tested this yogurt making machine and were satisfied with the performance and quality of the yogurt it produced. However, if you are looking for a multi-purpose yogurt maker, try this Instant Pot Duo as it can not just work as a yogurt maker but also as a slow cooker, pressure cooker, food warmer, steamer, and rice cooker.
Greek yogurt is a great option for health. Research by Harvard University has shown that yogurt is associated with numerous health benefits, including improved gastrointestinal and cardiovascular health, reduced risk of certain types of cancer, improved weight management, and enhanced immune responses. That’s why having the best yogurt maker comes in handy to make yogurt at home. After thorough research of more than 40 hours, and testing dozens of Yogurt makers by our professional testing team, we’ve come up with the 10 best yogurt making machines you can buy online. Rest assured, these yogurt makers were tested from every aspect including, build, features, performance, capacity, and price.
Related: Best keto yogurts for a keto diet.
Our Top Picks
- Best Overall: Euro Cuisine YM80
- Best Multipurpose: Instant Pot Duo Yogurt Maker
- Best Automatic Temperature Control: Euro Cuisine YMX650
- Best Electric: Dash Greek Yogurt Maker
- Best Manual: Euro Cuisine GY50
- Best Stylish: Euro Cuisine YM460
- Best Premium: Bear Yogurt Maker
- Best For Regular Use: Proctor Silex 86300
- Best Durable: Country Trading Stainless Steel Yogurt Maker
- Best Budget: Americana Collection Elite EIM520M
Best Yogurt Makers You Can Buy in 2024
Euro Cuisine YM80
Features
What We Like
What We Don’t Like
Euro Cuisine YM80 Yogurt Maker is an excellent choice for its affordability and performance-oriented features that you get in the expensive yogurt makers. This electric yogurt maker has the capacity for seven glass containers to let you make different yogurt flavors to serve your family the yogurt they like. The 42-ounce capacity and compact body make it an ideal choice for the countertop.
This yogurt making machine comes with an On/Off indicator that enables you to know about the progress of the yogurt fermentation, and you can adjust the timing for making the yogurt with the required consistency.
I love the ease of use and design of this Euro Cuisine yogurt maker. It produced yogurt that tasted fresh and better than the packaged yogurt by reputed brands in the superstores. I liked the separate partitions and easy-to-grab glass containers for making yogurt of different flavors. One thing I must appreciate about Euro Cuisine YM80 is its ability to expand the capacity as you can buy additional jars with an expansion rack making them 14 in total.
As far as the downside, this model lacks the auto shutoff, which is a must-have feature for multitasker moms. However, you can manually monitor the process from the timer display.
The overall operation and utility of the Euro Cuisine YM80 are excellent. Seven jars with lids enable you to make delicious yogurt flavors. You don’t have to hassle much with separating and making the yogurt, as you can serve each family member with the yogurt of their choice.
Comparison Note: The Euro Cuisine YM80, YMX650, and YM460 all offer yogurt-making capabilities, but differ in their capacity and features. The YM80 is a compact and budget-friendly option, ideal for smaller households. The YMX650 offers a larger capacity and a digital timer, catering to those who want more convenience. The YM460 stands out with its larger size and ability to make larger batches. Depending on your needs and budget, you can choose the Euro Cuisine yogurt maker that suits you best.
If you want dairy-free products, try these best dairy-free yogurts.
Instant Pot Duo Yogurt Maker
Features
What We Like
What We Don’t Like
If you prefer a multipurpose yogurt maker, the Instant Pot Duo is the best choice for yogurt making, due to its automatic mechanism. This model combines seven different appliances: a slow cooker, pressure cooker, warmer, steamer, rice cooker, saute pan, and yogurt maker. Although the combination is ideal for various needs, it is comparatively more expensive than the models I’ve reviewed.
The design of the Instant Pot Duo yogurt maker is simple yet elegant. It features a touch control on the front to give you a complete command of the options. The display is large enough to give feedback on what’s happening inside the pot. You can change the pressure from high to low using the touch control display. It comes included with the steam rack to let you have a diverse set of options.
The Instant Pot Duo yogurt maker is your one-stop solution for making the best yogurt. Its pre-programmed yogurt button lets you make yogurt in no time. The process is straightforward – start the yogurt making option, put the milk inside the pot, and wait for 8-12 hours to get the yogurt of your desired consistency.
While testing, I found the automatic yogurt making feature quite helpful. The process is the same, as you don’t have to tweak the temperature and timer settings every time. The one-touch operation is intuitive and lets me operate the yogurt maker without hassle. Since this is an all-in-one yogurt maker, you can cook several other dishes without having separate appliances.
However, if you want to use the cooker feature you must be careful when releasing the pressure valve. If you are not used to pressuring cooking, it may not be easy to grab for a few attempts as it may cause hand burns in a try to open the usual way. The steam release valve design is unsuitable for pressure release instead a side lever would be a better option.
Comparison Note: The Instant Pot Duo Yogurt Maker, Dash Greek Yogurt Maker, and Euro Cuisine YMX650 are the best yogurt making appliances. Instant Pot Duo is a multipurpose appliance that offers pressure cooking, while the Dash Greek Yogurt Maker is a compact and budget-friendly option. The Euro Cuisine YMX650 offers digital controls and a larger capacity.
If you want a multi-purpose yogurt maker, I would recommend going for the Instant Pot which offers many other cooking options in one appliance. The bigger LED display, easy-to-use touch controls, and quick yogurt making process are what make it the best yogurt maker available today.
You can also buy it at Walmart
Euro Cuisine YMX650
Features
What We Like
What We Don’t Like
Who says that variety has to be complicated? The Euro Cuisine YMX650 Digital Automatic yogurt maker offers a simple solution to prepare a range of yogurt flavors at home. Like its predecessor models, YMX650 also comes with seven small glass jars to make and store different flavors beforehand.
This model features a timer display to show the yogurt processing time. The best part is that it comes with a timer and an alarm to let you know when your yogurt processing is complete so that you won’t have to constantly monitor the machine. Besides, the timer enables you to set the time and consistency of yogurt you want. These features are lacking in its predecessor model YM80.
I was impressed by the overall yogurt making performance of the Euro Cuisine YMX650. I was able to get amazingly thick yogurt in around 10 hours. Make to add flavors of your choice into the lukewarm milk while adding milk to the jars. Besides, take extra care of adjusting the machine lid after setting up the jars inside it.
The auto timer was really helpful and I didn’t need to set the temperature and shutdown timer due to the presence of a 15-hour auto timer. However, you can also adjust the time as per your choice. The LED light indicator is the best companion to let you know when you need to transfer the prepared yogurt for serving.
The only downside I found in the Euro Cuisine YMX650 is that although the glass jars have a great build, they require extra care while handling. Besides, the timer display is not very visible and needs effort to see the readings.
The YMX650 is not only a reliable yogurt maker, but also one of the best budget electric yogurt makers on the market. With all of its features and its low price tag, it’s an excellent value for your money.
You can also buy it at Walmart
Dash Greek Yogurt Maker with LCD Display
Features
What We Like
What We Don’t Like
The Dash Greek yogurt maker is an excellent choice for anyone who loves Greek yogurt. It’s easy to use and affordable, especially considering how much you’d spend on Greek yogurt at the store. Since Greek yogurt is strained to remove excess water for a thick, creamy consistency, the Dash yogurt maker delivers everything in this regard.
The design of the Dash Greek Yogurt Maker is simple and features a start/stop button. Like YMX650, this model also lets you set the total cooking time of yogurt. Although the process and design of these yogurt makers may look similar, the included filter makes the real difference and allows for the removal of excess water, giving the yogurt a thick consistency.
Overall, this compact model can fit all of the accessories that come with it to save some cabinet space. Besides, this is the perfect choice if you are single, or have a nuclear family. However, if you have a bigger family, you may need to look for a bigger model. The best part – this model is dishwasher safe.
You can also buy it at Walmart, eBay
Euro Cuisine GY50
Features
What We Like
What We Don’t Like
Euro Cuisine’s GY50 is another excellent Greek yogurt maker that allows you to make Greek yogurt at home. Unlike Dash Greek yogurt maker, this model can hold up to two quarts of yogurt, so it’s a time-saver if you want to make large batches of Greek yogurt.
Despite its plastic construction, the build quality of GY50 is exceptional and made with BPA-free food-grade material. With its sleek design and innovative features, the Euro Cuisine GY50 is sure to last long. No more paper bags or cheesecloths are needed because the built-in filter of this model lets you achieve the required consistency by filtering the excess water.
The downside is that this is an analog model with no electric option, so you’ll miss the automatic yogurt-making process. However, this is not a big deal if you looking for a budget option to make large batches of Greek yogurt.
Overall, Euro Cuisine is an excellent choice for making quality yogurt. The spacious container allows for making ample yogurt for potluck dinners or breakfasts for a big gathering. You can preserve the freshness of the yogurt by keeping the container in the refrigerator.
You can also buy it at Walmart, eBay
Euro Cuisine YM460
Features
What We Like
What We Don’t Like
If you want to buy a premium yogurt maker with a thermometer and compact design, the Euro Cuisine YM460 is the best pick for you. It has a simple design that ditches out touch controls or an LCD screen that most other yogurt makers follow. The inside has a glass jar to make servings of the required quantity.
If you have limited counter space, the Euro Cuisine YM460 is an ideal choice with minimal design. Despite its small and compact body, it packs features that you won’t get from other competitors. The glass jar can fit snugly inside the body, and you can monitor the fermentation progress throughout the process.
Still, you can get 2 quarts (8 cups) of yogurt for the whole family serving. The best part of this model is its stainless steel thermometer that comes in handy to control the temperature. You Can also try these best infrared cooking thermometers to monitor the temperature of cooking and baking appliances.
The performance of the Euro Cuisine YM460 is no less than its competitor models. My team analyzed it against other models while testing, and it performed higher than our expectations.
Like the Euro Cuisine YMX650, the YM460 has an issue with the lid. The lids are not as secure as you would expect from a product that involves food handling. The lid on the glass jar is slightly loose, but not to the extent that you have to worry about spills every time you make the yogurt.
Overall, Euro Cuisine YM460 Greek Yogurt Maker is the ultimate choice if you want freshly made and healthy yogurt for the family. It has a compact, minimalistic design that blends well with the kitchen layout. Furthermore, three color choices perk things up: green, red, and white.
You can also buy it at Walmart
Bear Yogurt Maker
Features
What We Like
What We Don’t Like
The Bear Yogurt Maker is the best yogurt maker which boasts a trendy design bundled with excellent performance. You don’t want to miss out on this yogurt maker as it has a set of innovative features including a unique digital display. Timer settings and LED indicators come standard with the Bear yogurt maker, which helps automate the whole process.
This model carries a traditional design including a digital display, and a power button to control the functions and monitor the yogurt-making process. The display is large enough to be visible from a range allowing you to observe the temperature.
The BPA-free food-grade plastic used in the construction of this yogurt maker makes it a good option. The inside bucket is spacious and keeps the original taste without contaminating the food.
Although it lacks a strainer for making Greek yogurt, it still works well. Since making Greek yogurt takes more time than regular yogurt, you have to keep track of the temperature constantly.
The Bear yogurt maker also enables you to ferment cheese. However, you’ll need to follow the cheese making process, which requires heating and fermenting cheese at 140 degrees for six hours.
Apart from its being expensive, the Bear Yogurt Maker does not have much to complain about. One thing that needs improvement is a manual for instructions and recipes. If you are new to yogurt making, you may require additional help to operate and understand its features.
The Bear Greek Yogurt Maker is the best choice if you need a large display and an LED indicator for monitoring fermentation progress. Though it costs slightly more than the analog yogurt maker, it is worth every penny.
You can also buy it at Walmart, Bear Electronics
Proctor Silex 86300
Features
What We Like
What We Don’t Like
Proctor Silex 86300 is the best yogurt maker for making regular and Greek yogurt. It is convenient to use due to the large display, touch controls, and instruction manual to better understand this appliance. Its airtight storage gives you the utility to store yogurt in the fridge to keep it fresh.
Although the Proctor Silex 86300 yogurt maker looks simple, it has a modern outlook. The body is compact and doesn’t take up much space on the countertop. You can operate it with the help of a touch-enabled LCD to have a clear sight of the temperature and to control the timer for making yogurt with good consistency.
The best part of Proctor Silex 86300 is that it is easy to operate; Add the ingredients in the machine, plug the switch, set the timer, and let the machine do its job.
While testing, I noticed that this yogurt maker needs some improvement in the utility department. It requires a separate container for making a large batch of yogurt. Only this way, you can prepare a batch and store it in the refrigerator.
Overall, the Proctor Silex 86300 perfectly fits the budget while being able to make both regular and Greek yogurt. It has a simple yet intuitive design that helps you operate the machine smoothly, and make yogurt for a small family, though it may need extra preparation time for large servings.
You can also buy it at Walmart, Proctor Silex
Country Trading Stainless Steel Yogurt Maker
Features
What We Like
What We Don’t Like
The Country Trading Co. yogurt maker is an excellent option for anyone who loves yogurt without worrying about the hassle of an electric yogurt maker. This simple and compact model has no timers, which could increase the risk of overheating. The stainless steel build and glass components make it a durable appliance for everyday use.
The operation, cleaning, and usage of this model are straightforward. The overall compact build can easily fit on any countertop while the stainless steel and glass materials ensure plastic-free and healthy yogurt, while the steel lid at the top keeps it airtight for usage.
The best part of this machine is its airtight lids of glass jars to help you maintain freshness even after storing yogurt for a few days. With this Country Trading yogurt maker, you can make soft cheese, sour cream, lactose-free yogurt, cultured butter, and other fermented foods.
I tested and analyzed the whole yogurt-making process with this yogurt maker. It only takes eight hours to complete the fermentation process, which is standard for most yogurt makers.
One drawback I noticed in this model is that even though the jars are airtight, you still have to maintain temperature while making the yogurt.
Overall, the Country Trading Yogurt Maker is the best choice for those who want a consistent and thick yogurt for breakfast or those who are on a keto diet.
You can also buy it at Walmart, Country Trading
Americana Collection Elite EIM520M
Features & Specs:
What We Like
What We Don’t Like
American Collection’s yogurt maker is perhaps the best choice for a beginner-level chef to practice the skills. For the start, it has a convenient user interface with a simple power button. The removable freezer bowl makes handling the yogurt making process quite easy.
Talking about its capacity, it has 1-quart bowl which makes it possible to make a single batch of yogurt, enough for friends groups, or families. Not only yogurt, but you can also make gelatos, ice creams, sorbets, and other frozen desserts in this machine.
However, I do find it troublesome that it has no LED to show time or temperature. It lacks the option to adjust the temperature settings. Yet, it is a simple and smart unit ideal for the beginner chef to create a variety of desserts.
You can also buy it at eBay, Walmart
What to Look for When Buying A Yogurt Maker?
Several considerations are a must to keep in mind when buying a yogurt maker. Each person’s preference can differ according to their requirements, but the criteria for selecting the best yogurt maker remain the same. Have a look at these considerations!
Size
The size of the yogurt maker is crucial and, foremost, the most important thing you must consider when buying one. You must first figure out how much serving you need for the family and how much space you have on the countertop to store the yogurt makers. Some yogurt makers are larger, while some have small containers. Choose the option that fits your preference and feels convenient.
Mode of Operation
The mode of operation of the yogurt maker is the second most important consideration you may want to investigate when buying. Electric yogurt makers are versatile and provide more options than non-electric yogurt. You can have options like timers, LED displays, and settings for hardness on the electric yogurt maker. If these are not your preference, you may opt for the non-electric yogurt makers.
Features
Having extra features at your disposal is always helpful whenever buying a yogurt maker. You may look for the yogurt maker with extra bells and whistles. Many yogurt makers offer options like timers and auto-shutoff that may be handy for most users. You may opt for the adjustable temperature to get the right consistency. It’s all about what you prefer and may find helpful when buying the yogurt maker.
Preparation Time
Yogurt preparation time is one of the primary concerns when buying a yogurt maker. It can range between four to eight hours, depending on the model you purchase. It also depends on the thickness and consistency you would like for the yogurt. Choose the yogurt maker with an adjustable preparation time to get the desired flavor you crave for the serving.
Health and Safety
These days, BPA-free plastic is the way to buy kitchen gadgets. Having a yogurt maker with this chemical can seriously affect overall health. I have listed the 9 best yogurt makers, so you won’t have to worry about consuming dangerous chemicals in your food.
How We Tested?
When determining the best yogurt maker among several options, we have tested them against certain factors and characteristics. Based on those rankings, we have compiled this list of top yogurt makers you can buy for the money. These considerations include preparation time, safety, controls, mode of operation, and overall capacity.
The above list contains the yogurt makers that are BPA-free and free from any toxic material that can prove unhealthy. We have included electric and non-electric yogurt makers for convenience selection as buyers have diverse usage depending on their preferences.
Furthermore, the list also clearly has diverse size and capacity options. It has yogurt makers suitable for a single serving and some for family or multiple servings. The preparation time is another aspect that we have considered when selecting these yogurt makers. Adjusting the time can let you prepare any yogurt type with perfect consistency. For more information on how we tested, check out our testing methodology.
Why Trust TheLadyChef
At TheLadyChef, we have a team of experts who know all about kitchen accessories. They put products to the test and then write in-depth reviews. We follow the same process for the yogurt maker, ensuring that it meets all of our set criteria. We want our readers to have the best information possible before purchasing. TheLadyChef has quickly become the go-to source for kitchen accessory reviews and recipes with thousands of happy readers.